It’s Christmas! How About a Little Truce?


Prince Charles? Would you go to war if he were assassinated?Prince Charles? Would you go to war if he were assassinated?

Suppose Prince Charles of the UK were assassinated while he was traveling in South Korea.

Would you consider that a justification for the US going to war with, say, Japan?


And yet in essence that’s what precipitated the First World War, or The Great War, as it was called.

Archduke Ferdinand of Austria and his wife were shot dead in Sarajevo, and because of a series of treaties binding various countries to fight for each other, Europeans suddenly found themselves at war with each other in August 1914.

Yes, it was a bit more complicated than that; there were long-simmering rivalries and feuds among the various nations, etc., etc. 

Given the precipitating event, the killing of a prince whom no one really liked, it was necessary for the propaganda machines of the warring nations to flip into high gear, whipping up the populations into a frenzy of irrational hatred for the “enemy”.

And so it came to pass that on Christmas Eve, 1914, during a lull in the fighting, with German troops on one side of the trench and French and British troops on the other, the soldiers heard their “enemies” singing Christmas carols across the divide.

An informal “truce” was declared and the “enemy” factions joined together to sing carols, trade cigarettes and booze, and discover the common humanity that they all shared.

Joyeux Noel (Widescreen)

Starring Diane Kruger, Benno Fürmann, Guillaume Canet, Natalie Dessay, Rolando Villazón

That’s a true story.

Alas, it doesn’t have a happy ending.

The next day, the troops were reluctant to fight against their new-found “friends”, and so each side began to warn the other of when a surprise shelling was about to occur.

Needless to say, once the generals found out about the “truce”, they were not amused. There was going to be hell to pay, and they exacted their own form of punishment on the “disobedient” troops.

As I said, that’s a true story, and it formed the basis of one of my favorite movies of the last few years, 2006’s Joyeux Noel (that’s French for “Merry Christmas”).

And now it’s been turned into an opera, Silent Night with a libretto (based directly on the movie’s screenplay) by Mark Campbell and music by Kevin Puts; it was the winner of the 2012 Pulitzer Prize for music.


Silent Night the OperaSilent Night the Opera

Originally staged by the Minnesota Opera in 2011, it has now come to Opera Philadelphia. I’m going to see this afternoon’s performance, and I have to say, I haven’t been this excited about a new musical work since, oh, since Stephen Sondheim’s Passion nearly 20 years ago.

Leave a Reply