Action and Capers

Quote of the day:

I never forget a face, but in your case I’ll be glad to make an exception.
—Groucho Marx

Yesterday’s Q&A at electoral-vote.com was devoted entirely to non-political questions and there were several about movies. I especially liked the answers, or at least part of the answers to a couple of them, so I’m going to re-publish them here.

For the full Q&A go to https://www.electoral-vote.com/evp2025/Senate/Maps/Jul26.html.

Here was their answer to the top ten action films with female leads:

(V) & (Z) answer: We recognize that there are different ideas of what it takes to make an action film, and what it takes to qualify as a “lead.” However, by OUR definitions, here is our Top 10, in chronological order:

  1. Notorious (1946): Ingrid Bergman must have been thrilled to land a role like this; such an opportunity did not come often for actresses of her generation.
  2. Star Wars, Episode IV: A New Hope (1977): Princess Leia (Carrie Fisher) isn’t in the middle of the film very much, but she’s awfully important in the first and third acts.
  3. Aliens (1986): Ripley (Sigourney Weaver) might be the single-most intimidating character on this list.
  4. Terminator 2: Judgment Day (1991): The first one was good, but this one was better, and this is also the one where Sarah Connor (Linda Hamilton) began to drive events, rather than just react to them.
  5. Speed (1994): Yes, Officer Jack Traven (Keanu Reeves) does a lot of the dangerous things, but it’s Annie Porter (Sandra Bullock) who is actually driving the bus.
  6. X-Men (2000): The most powerful character in the movie, by far, is Jean Grey (Famke Janssen). And Storm (Halle Berry) is no slouch, either.
  7. Lara Croft: Tomb Raider (2001): When this film came out, there were all kinds of articles about how Angelina Jolie was launching a new era in female-led actions films. We think the actresses in the six previous films on the list, among others, would disagree. Still, Tomb Raider was a great action flick.
  8. Kill Bill: Vol. 1 (2003): While The Bride (Uma Thurman) kicked a lot of ass, we assume she did not take names, because everyone was dead by the time she was done.
  9. Spy (2015): It’s a shame this action-comedy didn’t get as much attention as it deserved, because Melissa McCarthy was great, maybe even better than she was in Bridesmaids.
  10. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story (2016): Jyn Erso (Felicity Jones) could give Leia a run for her money. Too bad the other Star Wars films of the last 10 years weren’t this good.

When films are part of a series, we chose only the one that we think is the best “female-led action film” of the set,
though we abide by the Lucasfilm convention that Rogue One is a standalone film, and not part of the Skywalker saga.

Notorious is one of my top five favorite Hitchcock films, of course. It’s a spy film and it’s a love story and it’s a suspense movie all rolled into one. I don’t think I’ve ever thought of it as an action film, but sure, for its day, why not? Its script by Ben Hecht is one of the best that Hitch ever worked with and it has the longest kiss ever put on film up till then. I’ve lost count of the number of times I’ve seen it.

Ingrid and Carey in Notorious.

I’d also like to give a special shout out to Spy. Melissa McCarthy plays a CIA analyst who is in love with the field agent Jude Law, and through a series of events she ends up having to go out in the field herself. She is hilarious. I’ve watched it at least twice and expect to watch it several more times. 

Melissa McCarthy in Spy.

Then there was the question about “caper” movies:

(V) & (Z) answer: We’re just going to stick with the format of the previous answer, and give you 10, in chronological order (starting with a film that makes both lists):

  1. Notorious

    (1946): There are a number of Hitchcock films that could make this list, but this is the one that fits best, we think. Hitch was born to make films like this.

  2. Ocean’s Eleven

    (1960): The film itself is only so-so, but it makes the list because watching the Rat Pack in action is such a treat.

  3. The Manchurian Candidate

    (1962): This is a considerably better film than the previous one, with Frank Sintra actually getting to show off his acting chops.

  4. It’s a Mad, Mad, Mad, Mad World

    (1963): A lot of films on this list have unbelievable casts, but this one might be the most loaded of all, a veritable who’s who of mid-20th-century comedy. And it’s a rip-roaring adventure, to boot, one that still echoes in American culture, all these years later. We always wonder, when we visit an In-N-Out Burger, how many people know the crossed palm trees in front of every location are an homage to “the big W.”

  5. The Godfather

    (1972): We realize that this is not usually considered a caper film, but hear us out. The entire second half of the film, from the time that Michael Corleone takes over as don, is a giant con meant to lull the other families into complacency, so that Michael can eventually strike like a cobra, and reassert the Corleones as the dominant family in New York. That sounds like a caper to us.

  6. The Sting

    (1973): We’re not ranking the films here, but if we were, this pretty much has to be #1, right?

  7. Dirty Rotten Scoundrels

    (1988): There is no way we could make a list like this, and not find room for at least one film by Michael Caine, who clearly had an affinity for caper films (The Italian Job, Gambit, Going in Style, etc.). But this is Caine’s best, in our view. And we did not realize, until writing this answer, that if Caine is the king of capers, Steve Martin is the prince. It’s actually Martin who shows up twice here, and he could plausibly have made one or two other appearances (for example, for his take on Inspector Clouseau).

  8. Sneakers

    (1992): Another film with an absolutely loaded cast, including three Oscar winners (Robert Redford, Sidney Poitier, and Ben Kingsley) and another five nominees (Dan Aykroyd, David Strathairn, River Phoenix, James Earl Jones, and Mary McDonnell). It’s quite a thing when Stephen Tobolowsky, one of the great character actors of our time, barely makes the top ten most notable cast members. And the script is great, to boot.

  9. The Usual Suspects

    (1995): If you haven’t seen it, and you ever plan to do so, we’ll just say that you’ll be very surprised to learn who plays Keyser Söze.

  10. The Spanish Prisoner

    (1997): Director and screenwriter David Mamet has turned into a real jerk, but this movie, his magnum opus, is still great (and was made before his “jerk” period).

Again, I never thought of Notorious as a caper movie, but anything that might encourage more views of that wonderful movie is ok by me.

I saw the 1960 Ocean’s Eleven at the Neptune when it played there, probably in 1960, and it taught me a new word, which I won’t mention here because it will spoil the ending for those who haven’t seen it. Actually, my uncle Reed had to explain it to me, so I missed the sweet irony of the ending until we were walking out of the movie theater.

Angela Lansbury gave one her finest performances in The Manchurian Candidate, of course. Was Frank Sinatra in it as well? Cool.

Lansbury in Manchurina Candidate.

David Mamet was responsible for so many great plays and films, and then he became a jerk. I hope I die before I get to his age. Oh, wait. He’s only a year and a half older than I am! But he became a jerk years ago. I guess I’m ok. Anyway The Spanish Prisoner is a fine movie.

Leave a Reply