The Civil War & A Real Life Bond Villain

This week’s Q&A at electoral-vote.com was a respite from all the political news, so it was all non-political questions and answers, many of them quite interesting. Go and read the whole thing.

But here are a couple that I picked out that pertain to the Civil War and to a real-life Bond villain.

Battle of Shiloh.

https://www.electoral-vote.com/evp2026/Senate/Maps/Nov21.html#QA-5

P.R. in Arvada, CO, asks: As you were learning about the Civil War, what was the most surprising/impressive thing you learned, what was the best nugget of information you learned that you could drop into a conversation, and what was the thing you learned that made you go “No way can that be true” but is?

(Z) answers: As to your first question, this probably isn’t exciting to anyone who is not a historian of the Civil War, I suppose. But Eric Foner’s book Free Soil, Free Labor, Free Men: The Ideology of the Republican Party before the Civil War was eye-opening, because it made clear how a majority of Northerners could be anti-slavery without being anti-slavery in the way that modern Americans would be anti-slavery (the main concern for the majority of anti-slavery folks was the economic harm wrought upon the country by slavery, not the morality of the institution).

And the classic nugget of information that delights students and non-students alike is that the first major battle of the Civil War (First Bull Run) was fought substantially on the farm of a man named Wilmer McLean. The farm was wrecked, and McLean decided to move so that the war would not bother him and his family again. He moved to… Appomattox Court House, and his house ended up being used for the surrender of Robert E. Lee and the Army of Northern Virginia. The people present wanted souvenirs, so much of the interior of McLean’s house was ruined. In short, the Civil War effectively started and ended at the same guy’s house, and the property got wrecked both times.

Since so many people know that one, I’ll add another that is somewhat less famous. Because they understood painkillers at the time, but did not particularly understand addiction, one in four Civil War soldiers was a morphine addict by 1880. In an effort to solve the problem, a fellow in Atlanta named John C. Pemberton developed a product meant to help wean them off the opioids. The active ingredient in this product was cocaine—again, they didn’t really grasp addiction back then. Obviously, it didn’t work. Still, the product went on to be a great success. It was, of course, Coca-Cola.

As to “hard to believe it’s true,” there are a whole bunch of “it was a smaller world back then” Civil War stories. Perhaps the best known took place when First Son Robert Todd Lincoln, then a civilian, was traveling via train late at night in New Jersey. He was changing trains, stumbled, and fell off the platform into the path of an oncoming train. He was lifted up and rescued at the last moment by… Edwin Booth, brother of John Wilkes Booth. Edwin was a devoted Unionist, while John was a white supremacist and secessionist, and would, of course go on to assassinate Robert’s father (about 2 years later).

And if you want a more substantive “hard to believe it’s true,” then how about this: About twice as many soldiers in the Civil War died from disease than from enemy bullets. That is true even if you count soldiers who died of infected battle wounds as combat casualties. World War II was actually the first major American war where bullets killed more soldiers than did germs.


 

L.B. in Bozeman, MT, asks: What’s a notable or interesting historical event that would make a good movie but hasn’t been made yet?

(Z) answers: I am going to give a Civil War answer. There have been many movies made about the Battle of Gettysburg. There has not been a movie (beyond documentaries) made about the Battle of Shiloh or the Battle of Antietam, which both took place in 1862. The former is quite dramatic, as the Union snatched victory from the jaws of defeat. Plus, the main characters would be Ulysses S. Grant and William T. Sherman, which would be juicy roles. The latter is quite momentous, and it would work well to set Abraham Lincoln up as the main protagonist, Frederick Douglass as the deuteragonist and George McClellan as the antagonist.


Y.H. in Toronto, ON, Canada, asks: Is Elon Musk as close to a real-life personification of a Bond villain as we’ve seen in many, many years, probably several decades? And which would you say he’s closest to?

I say Max Zorin. A tech guy with celebrity-level public persona, enormous wealth, a massive business empire and a desire to reshape entire industries (plural).

(Z) answers: Musk is certainly the most Bond-like villain we’ve seen recently, though I don’t know about several decades. Martin Shkreli is pretty Bond-villain-like. Maybe Elizabeth Holmes, too.

And I think the closest fit is Hugo Drax. They are both people who built their fortunes in industry, and then turned their eyes toward conquering space. It is true, I will concede, that Drax actually plans a genocide, whereas Musk merely indulges in the kind of rhetoric that sometimes leads genocide.

Leave a Reply