
A couple more thoughts on Damn Yankees.

Douglass Wallop, who wrote the novel on which the musical was based, received a co-writer credit for writing the book of the musical along with George Abbott. But I have a very strong suspicion that he contributed little or nothing to the actual writing of Damn Yankees, and yet he earned a substantial royalty for the rest of his life that probably far surpassed anything he earned from his novel writing career. He must have had a very clever agent.
I base this suspicion on a couple things. I tried looking up information on his contribution to the script and couldn’t find anything, and all I did find was an article that he published in the New York Times a year after the show opened in which all he said was that the show was based on his novel. No mention that he contributed to writing the show.
Also, I have tried on more than one occasion to actually read the novel. My high school library had a copy of The Year the Yankees Lost the Pennant and I made a valiant effort to read it then, but I found it, well, boring, not terribly amusing, and very different from the show. I didn’t get more than a couple chapters into it.
I tried again in the 90s and ordered a copy from Amazon. That time I made it about half way through, but I felt the same way. It was boring, and although it had the basic situation that we find in the show, most of what is amusing, including the secondary characters, is just not there. The tone of the novel is very different from that of the musical.
So I truly don’t think he helped to write the show.
If anyone has information to the contrary, I am happy to be corrected and enlightened.
In the song “A Little Brains, A Little Talent” there is this little snippet:
You’ve seen that sign that says George Washington once slept here.
Well, tho’ nobody spied him,
Guess who was beside him?
But in the movie this is replaced with
Delilah claimed a haircut made her man a weakling,
But when she turned the lamps on,
Guess who was with Samson?
Why the change?
My guess is that some Hollywood exec feared the idea of Lola boasting about sleeping beside the Father of Our Country would not play well in the heartland, so he demanded a rewrite.
I remember my mother taking Randy Klopp and me to a Mount Gretna production of Damn Yankees sometime in the early 60s. It was very well done as all those summer Mount Gretna shows usually were, but the thing I remember the most, the line that got the biggest laugh, was a line of Lola’s in the second act. She’s telling Joe that she’s actually 170 years old and that when Applegate found her she was the ugliest girl in Providence, Rhode Island. Well, that’s what it says in the script and that’s what Lola says in the movie, but at Mount Gretna, Lola said she had been the ugliest girl in Lebanon, PA. It brought down the house. I suspect that line is usually changed whenever it’s done in summer stock or high school or community theater productions.

And finally, just a reminder of how talented Gwen Verdon was. She had a lotta talent.