
There’s a quote that I remember from Walter Kerr’s Tragedy and Comedy, and I even used it in preparing a speech for a public speaking course I took at Penn State.
This may account for the mysterious distinction Groucho Marx once made between an amateur and a professional. An amateur thinks it’s funny, Groucho said, if you dress a man up as an old lady, put him in a wheel chair, and give the wheel chair a push that sends it spinning down a slope toward a stone wall. The device, of course, has given us all our variations of Charley’s Aunt. What is funny for a professional? “For a pro,” Groucho said, “it’s got to be a real old lady.” The best comedy makes no waivers. It is so. And it is harsh.
Perhaps Larry Gelbart knew of that Groucho quote when he was writing The Notorious Landlady.
I saw that movie, at the Neptune Theatre naturally, when it came out back in the 1960s, and I the only thing I remembered from it is that scene. I just watched it again the other evening for the first time since then and found it to be an uneven comedy—it starts off well for its first half hour, then flounders a bit during its middle, and picks up again towards the end.