Biblical scholars believe that, based on internal evidence, the Gospel of Mark was the first of the four gospels to be written.
Mark does not contain a nativity story; it begins the saga of Jesus with his baptism by John the Baptist and then his adoption by a voice from heaven:
At that time Jesus came from Nazareth in Galilee and was baptized by John in the Jordan. Just as Jesus was coming up out of the water, he saw heaven being torn open and the Spirit descending on him like a dove. And a voice came from heaven: “You are my Son, whom I love; with you I am well pleased.”
—Mark 1:9-11
When the writers of the Gospels of Matthew and Luke came to write their versions of the Jesus story, they each included a different nativity story, and the nativity story that most Christians learn in Sunday school and that is repeated elsewhere is a conflation of these two tales.
Given that each of the gospels was written decades after the historical Jesus died and was based on oral traditions and previously written records, there is no reason to accept the myth of Jesus’s virgin birth, especially as it was at least partially based on the mistranslation of a passage from the Jewish scriptures or Old Testament.
In any case the American Bible Society reports in its 16th annual State of the Bible that
While more than half of Americans, 53%, still believe in the miracle of Jesus’ resurrection, only 49% believe the virgin birth is at least probably true. This is the first time a major national survey has recorded belief in the virgin birth dropping below 50%. In 2017, data from the Pew Research Center showed that 66% of Americans believed Jesus was born to a virgin. That share declined from 73% in 2014.
You can read the full article.
I’m not certain whether this is progress or not. History tells us that religiosity moves in waves or cycles and there are periods in our history that have been given the name the Great Awakenings, although I would refer to them as darkenings or something similar.
It’s actually irrelevant to Christianity whether Jesus was adopted by a god, born from a virgin, or even burst full grown out of a god’s head. All that matters is his death and resurrection, supposedly to forgive the sins of humanity, and that seems like a pretty idiotic method of conferring redemption. Why didn’t the god simply wave its magic wand (or whatever) and say you’re redeemed? Much easier and less messy, in my opinion. Perhaps followed periodically by blinking lights in the sky in all languages to remind everyone.
In any case, it seems that only 53% still believe in the mythical resurrection. I wonder if it has anything to do with the fact that it was Christians who voted the current Republican into the White House? To be fair it was evangelical Christians, Christian Nationalists, and a majority of the Catholics who voted that landed him there. Perhaps folks are looking at how hateful those Christians are and deciding they don’t want any part of it.
In related news, the Religion News Service reports that a majority of evangelical Christians don’t value empathy. I hope nobody is surprised by this.
A new survey from Washington, D.C.-based Public Religion Research Institute has found a new dividing line among Americans ahead of the 2026 midterm elections: empathy. According to a PRRI report released Tuesday (Oct. 20), Democrats (84%) and Independents (70%) are more likely than Republicans (53%) to see empathy as a benefit to society. Forty-three percent of Republicans see empathy as a danger if it leads society away from God.
Religious groups were also split. At least two-thirds of most major religious groups said empathy “is a foundational moral value for a healthy society,” as did 83% of religiously unaffiliated Americans. White evangelicals were the least likely to name empathy as a foundational social value (42%), and more than half of white evangelicals (54%) said, “empathy can become dangerous when it leads people away from building a society guided by God’s truth.”
Read the full article: An ‘empathy gap’ divides Americans ahead of the midterms